GagBase Logo Explore

Girl Scout Cookies vs. Homemade: Voted Worst YouTube Thumbnail

The image features a comparison of two Samoas-style cookies: a larger, prominently displayed cookie labeled 'MINE' (implying homemade) and a smaller cookie labeled 'GIRL SCOUTS' (referencing the original Girl Scout Cookies). Below this comparison is a partial YouTube thumbnail with the text 'Making Girl Scout Cookies At Home: Samoas | But Better' and a 'NEWS' logo in the bottom left corner. The bottom section of the image contains bold, attention-grabbing text stating 'THIS IS VOTED AS THE WORST THUMBNAIL IN YOUTUBE HISTORY', critiquing the original thumbnail's design, likely due to its exaggerated size comparison and clickbait-like presentation.
Make

Text content

THIS IS VOTED AS THE WORST THUMBNAIL IN YOUTUBE HISTORY

Overview

The image features a comparison of two Samoas-style cookies: a larger, prominently displayed cookie labeled 'MINE' (implying homemade) and a smaller cookie labeled 'GIRL SCOUTS' (referencing the original Girl Scout Cookies). Below this comparison is a partial YouTube thumbnail with the text 'Making Girl Scout Cookies At Home: Samoas | But Better' and a 'NEWS' logo in the bottom left corner. The bottom section of the image contains bold, attention-grabbing text stating 'THIS IS VOTED AS THE WORST THUMBNAIL IN YOUTUBE HISTORY', critiquing the original thumbnail's design, likely due to its exaggerated size comparison and clickbait-like presentation.

Origin notes

This image appears to be an edited screenshot of a YouTube video thumbnail. The original thumbnail likely promoted a recipe video for homemade Samoas cookies, emphasizing they are 'better' than store-bought Girl Scout versions. The added text at the bottom ('THIS IS VOTED...') transforms it into a meme mocking the thumbnail's perceived poor design, suggesting it was shared on social media platforms (e.g., Reddit, Twitter) to humorously critique YouTube thumbnail trends. The 'NEWS' watermark may indicate the original video was from a news or cooking channel, though the exact source is not explicitly stated.

Similar memes

This image is a screenshot of a public post from X (formerly Twitter) by verified gaming content creator Lucy James. The post opens with her text stating "this is the worst email I have ever received", followed by a screenshot of the unsolicited email sent to her. The email pitches a story titled "Experts Reveal Shocking Video of What our Hands Could Look Like if They Evolved for Gaming", paired with an image showing fictional altered hands with unusually long index and middle fingers next to a shot of hands holding a PlayStation controller to demonstrate the supposed utility of these evolved hands for gaming, plus a short introductory blurb about the growing popularity of gaming as a hobby and career. The humor stems from the absurd, pointless nature of the pitched story, making the email so ridiculous that Lucy labels it the worst she has ever received.

Gaming Creator Reacts to Ridiculous Email About Hands Evolving for Gaming

This image is a screenshot of…

An illustration meme featuring a man with a red YouTube logo superimposed over his face, standing with his right hand raised in a stopping gesture. To his left, a human brain is being held by an unseen hand. The man's dialogue reads: 'No thanks, I demonetized an educational video about World War II.' The image satirizes YouTube's perceived tendency to demonetize educational content on sensitive historical topics like World War II, contrasting the brain (symbolizing knowledge/education) with the man's refusal gesture (representing platform policies).

YouTube Demonetizing WWII Educational Videos

An illustration meme featurin…

This is a screenshot of a social media post from the verified official YouTube account that asks users: 'what's the first video you're going to watch in 2026?'. The top-voted comment from user pleffin_edwin replies with the joke '2 unskippable ads'. The joke pokes fun at the long-standing common user frustration with YouTube's frequent unskippable pre-video advertisements, implying that even several years into the future, unskippable ads will still be the first thing users encounter on the platform before they can watch any actual video.

YouTube Asks First 2026 Video, Unskippable Ads Joke

This is a screenshot of a soc…

A screenshot of a video thumbnail featuring Marques Brownlee (MKBHD), a popular tech YouTuber, wearing a red hoodie and pointing upwards with his index finger. The background shows a setup with dual monitors and speakers, typical of his studio. Below the image is a video title: 'Every Mistake I Made in 2025' by Marques Brownlee, with 172K views and posted 4 hours ago. A humorous timestamp '235:48:12' (235 hours, 48 minutes, 12 seconds) is displayed in the bottom right corner of the main image, exaggerating the video's length to an absurd degree for comedic effect, as real videos rarely exceed a few hours.

Marques Brownlee's 2025 Mistakes Video (235 Hours Long!)

A screenshot of a video thumb…

A tier list meme ranking various cookies across S (red), A (orange), B (yellow), C (light yellow), and D (green) tiers. The top-left corner features an image of a 'Danisa Butter Cookies' box. S tier contains a round cookie with small holes; A tier has a spiral-shaped cookie; B tier includes a rectangular sesame-covered cookie and a pretzel; C tier shows a plain round cookie; D tier humorously contains three spools of thread (playing on the pun 'thread' instead of 'cookie'). The meme uses visual humor by placing non-cookie items (thread spools) in the lowest tier as a joke.

Cookie Tier List Ranking

A tier list meme ranking vari…

A collage of two YouTube Shorts thumbnails presented side by side vertically. The top thumbnail, from 'Dhruv Rathee Shorts', features a man in a blue shirt standing with female (♀) and male (♂) gender symbols silhouetted behind him; the background includes large pink text 'MEN?'. The title reads 'Why Women live longer than men?' with 181K views from 1 day ago. The bottom thumbnail, from 'Mark Rober', shows an underwater scene where a person extends their hand with a bleeding finger (red blood visible), with a shark approaching in the distance. Its title is 'Testing if Sharks Can Smell a Drop of Blood' with 97M views from 2 years ago. The collage humorously contrasts the two video topics, implying a potential connection between men's risky behavior (e.g., testing sharks with blood) and the question of why women live longer.

Comparison of YouTube Shorts: Women's Longevity vs. Shark Blood Test

A collage of two YouTube Shor…

A screenshot of a Threads post from the verified YouTube account asking, 'what's the first video you're going to watch in 2026?' The post has 427,156 views, 3.3K likes, 945 comments, 76 reposts, and 41 shares. Below the post, the top comment by user 'pleffin_edwin' humorously responds with '2 unskippable ads,' which has 22K likes, 46 comments, 196 reposts, and 94 shares. The meme highlights the common frustration with unskippable YouTube ads by juxtaposing the innocent question with a sarcastic, relatable answer.

YouTube's 2026 First Video Question Gets Hilarious Ad Response

A screenshot of a Threads pos…

A screenshot of a social media Thread (resembling Twitter/X interface) from the official YouTube account. The post asks, 'what's the first video you're going to watch in 2026?' with engagement metrics: 3.3K likes, 945 comments, 76 reposts, and 41 shares. Below, the top comment by user 'pleffin_edwin' (with an animated profile picture) responds with '2 unskippable ads', which has 22K likes, 46 comments, 196 reposts, and 94 shares. The meme humorously highlights user frustration with unskippable ads on YouTube through sarcastic commentary.

YouTube Asks About 2026's First Video, Top Comment Roasts Unskippable Ads

A screenshot of a social medi…

This image is a screenshot of an MSN news article shared as a 9Gag post with the accompanying title 'We really aren't pissed off enough'. The news headline reports that a father died of grief after his 12-year-old daughter was raped and beheaded by an illegal immigrant; the article is credited to journalist Reanna Smith and marked as published 4 months before the screenshot was taken. Below the headline is a photo of the 12-year-old victim, a young blonde girl with a soft slight smile looking directly at the camera, standing in front of a plain light tiled wall. The post aims to express outrage at the horrific violent crime described, and argues that the general public is not sufficiently angry about this incident and related issues.

We really aren't pissed off enough

This image is a screenshot of…

A social media post featuring the story of a 9-year-old boy in France who survived alone for nearly two years after his mother left to live with her partner. The post includes three images: a headshot of a smiling boy in a plaid shirt, a boy with a red backpack walking down a path, and a boy sitting on the ground looking at a phone. The text explains how the child managed to survive without heat, hot water, or adult supervision by relying on canned food and cake, while still attending school daily and maintaining good grades. Teachers described him as polite, quiet, and hardworking but never suspected his home situation. The post raises questions about how this hardship went unnoticed and highlights the child's remarkable resilience.

9 Year Old Survives Two Years Alone After Mother Leaves, Still Attends School and Stays a Top Student

A social media post featuring…

This image is a screenshot of a post from the social media platform X (formerly Twitter). The post, made by user @goodgirlshadow (display name 'anonymous internet...'), includes a photo of two broken fortune cookies with no paper fortunes inside them. The caption above the photo reads: 'insane fortune cookie for a diagnosed schizophrenic to receive'. The joke relies on dark humor and a double meaning: for someone with schizophrenia, a fortune cookie without a fortune can feel like a disturbing, meta experience that plays into symptoms like hallucinations, delusions, or feeling disconnected from shared reality. The absence of a fortune becomes an ironic, unsettling 'message' that aligns with the challenges of living with the condition, creating a relatable (for those familiar with mental health topics) dark comedy moment. The post had garnered 231K views as of the timestamp shown, which is 4:28 on February 6, 2026.

Insane Fortune Cookie for Diagnosed Schizophrenic (Dark Humor Meme)

This image is a screenshot of…

A 'How it started vs How it's going' meme format contrasting two scenarios. Left side shows a Twitter/X tweet from Jill Foster (@JournalistJill) criticizing Rip Curl for dropping Bethany Hamilton (a shark attack survivor and surfer) from ad campaigns in favor of Sasha Lowerson. Right side shows a The Western Journal article headline: 'Retailer Closing 21 Stores, Loses $80 Million After Replacing Shark Survivor Model With Man Pretending to Be Woman' dated September 28, 2025. The meme implies因果关系 between the brand's advertising decision and subsequent financial failure.

Rip Curl's Ad Decision: From Dropping Shark Survivor to $80M Loss

A 'How it started vs How it's…